Tuesday, 4 August 2009

Assisted Suicide

Last week Diane Purdy won her appeal to have the DPP set out clearly whether it would prosecute in regard to anyone helping a terminal patient travel abroad to commit suicide. Which has to be a good thing doesn't it? Ms Purdy is suffering from MS, a condition that means she may be physically unable, when and if the time comes, she wishes to end her own life. She will need to travel abroad to do this where assisted suicide is legal. And naturally she wants her partner to be able to accompany her without fear of him being prosecuted when he returns to the UK.



Being terminally ill myself, and having been in such excruciating pain last week, made me think long and hard about all the implications surrounding assisted suicide. It is illegal in this country of course - but what exactly is the definition of 'assisting'?



If I decided I wanted to end my life and Martin passed me the bottle of pills with which to do it would he be guilty of it? Even if I was the one who actually took them? Or would he be guilty of 'assisiting' by merely sitting there and watching and not doing anything to stop me? It's a bit of a mine field isn't it and the law certainly needs clarifying.



There are the fears that too much clarification and the situation may arsie where dear old Aunt Mabel, terminally ill but living in a lovely (but very expensive) nursing home may be taken on an unexpected 'holiday' to Switzerland and not return.



Or that the terminally ill patient may feel pressure, whether real or imagined, to end their life early and save their relatives all the stress and strain and grief of watching them die slowly.



I believe we, the terminally ill, have a fundamental right to end our lives when they have become unbearable - but it must always be OUR decision. And the circumstances surrounding that decision will be different for each person naturally. And can change from time to time. Last week I had started to wonder just how much pain I could tolerate before I began to plan such a course of action. And yet this week I'm almost back to my 'normal' self.



However, one thing that did cross my mind in regard to those of us with a terminal illness who are not ready to end our lives yet - indeed we wish to extend them with the help of the new cancer drugs that are becoming available. I wonder how NICE would appraise any proposal on assisted suicide? It surely would be more cost effective than any life extending drug. Will NICE be approving assisted suicide as a treatment 'option' in the future?

Scary thought.....

6 comments:

Andy said...

Much as i appreciate that people with a terminal disease may feel the need to commit suicide, assisted or not it is not something that I agree with. My consultant said that if he was to tell me that I had ten years to live all sort of things could happen in that period from someone discovering a fantastic cure all drug to being hit by the proverbial double deck bus. Not only that in all honesty I do not think I could give some one a lethal overdose, I just could not live with my self.
Andy

chucky said...

As a fellow terminal cancer patient, one awaiting for the Nice decision so i can once again get Avastin, I can honestly say I have though about ending the pain that we all go through. Even getting to the point of standing on a sea wall, looking at the water, thinking that I cant do it any more and cant put my family through any more, but it was my husband who saved me, and 13 months later I am still dealing with the pain. Some days are good, some are bad and you are right, things do get better. its ahard decision but one we will all think about even if we dont say publicly. Much love and stay well. x

Sybil said...

This is and always has been a heavy subject and good arguments on both sides. It really is a very personal decision and as that it should remain a private decision. If I did believe in suicide I personally I would not expect anyone to assist me in my suicide. if I really wanted to do it I would make sure I was able to do it when I wanted to. and so the subject of assisted would not arise.
keep smiling.
Much Love Sybil xx

Andrew Petcher said...

Can't really make my mind up on this one. Difficult because I have no personal experience to draw on.

mortonlake said...

already read your last posting,working backwards.as a MS sufferer,albeit relatively mild,i feel for her,and understand how she feels.if it was me tho.?would i?yes.we dont allow our pets to suffer,now should we have to if we really dont want to.im still feeling sick hun.f*****g cancer.MS and all the other vile diseases.one day maybe we stop wasting our money and resources on killing each other and find a cure.too late for both of us.keep fighting girl.love mort.xxx

Sunil said...

Hey we have to do something to stop this type of things.

SUNIL

Cash Online Get Easy cash at your door step